Should I Manage My Own Rental Property?

Sailing your own ship through the choppy waters of rental property management can be an exhilarating journey, but it’s not without its perils. You’re considering taking the helm, armed with the allure of complete control and the potential for financial savings.

Deciding whether to manage your own rental property depends on your experience, availability, and willingness to handle all aspects of property management. Managing a rental property involves tasks such as finding tenants, collecting rent, handling repairs and maintenance, and dealing with any legal issues that may arise.

If you have the time, knowledge, and resources, self-management can save you money. However, if you lack the necessary expertise or if you prefer a hands-off approach, hiring a professional property management company might be a better option for you.

Like any seasoned captain, you must weigh the demands of time against the treacherous waves of tenant screening, maintenance, and the ever-looming threat of legal issues.

It’s essential to analyze whether you possess the necessary skills, resources, and resilience to navigate these challenges. As you stand at the crossroads, pondering the path that lies ahead, ask yourself if the satisfaction of steering your own course outweighs the peace of mind that might come from entrusting the wheel to a skilled property manager.

The answer isn’t as straightforward as it may seem, and the next sections will equip you with the compass you need to chart your course.

Key Takeaways

  • Self-management of rental property can potentially save on property management fees and maximize financial returns.
  • However, it requires a significant time commitment and dedication to tasks such as tenant screening and maintenance.
  • Effective tenant screening is crucial for successful rental property management, including thorough background and credit checks.
  • Maintenance and repairs are the responsibility of the landlord, and regular property maintenance is essential for maintaining property value.

Understanding Self-Management

When considering self-management for your rental property, it’s essential to weigh the potential savings against the responsibilities and time commitment it entails. If you decide to self-manage, you’ll sidestep property management fees, which can run from 8-12% of your monthly rent, plus additional costs. However, be prepared to handle maintenance issues, repairs, and the day-to-day tasks of managing a rental property.

Self-management means you’re directly involved in choosing and interacting with tenants. You’ll need to develop the acumen to screen tenants effectively, ensuring you select reliable individuals who’ll care for your property and pay rent punctually. This process can be time-consuming, and it’s critical to be thorough to avoid costly mistakes.

On the other hand, hiring a property management company frees up your time, potentially allowing you to focus on expanding your portfolio or other high-value tasks. But remember, even with a management company, you’re not entirely hands-off. You’ll still need to oversee their work and ensure your property management needs are being met efficiently.

Ultimately, the pros and cons of self-managing versus hiring a company boil down to your investment strategy, how much time and money you’re willing to invest, and whether you have the skills and patience to manage the property effectively.

Evaluating Financial Savings

Evaluating the financial savings of managing your rental property requires a clear analysis of potential costs and benefits, including the substantial property management fees you might incur. If you’re considering self-managing your rental, you’re likely motivated by the financial savings you anticipate. But it’s essential to weigh these against the time and effort you’ll invest.

Here are key factors to consider:

  • Property management fees typically take 8-12% of your monthly rent, which can significantly eat into your cash flow.
  • Rent collection and handling maintenance requests are tasks that, if not managed efficiently, can lead to higher expenses or lost income.
  • Hiring a property management company might initially seem costly, but their expertise could actually increase your investment property’s returns.
  • Self-managing your rental means no middleman, allowing you to potentially maximize your financial returns, provided you’re adept at the responsibilities involved.

Time Commitment Considerations

As a rental property owner, you must assess whether the substantial time investment required for tasks like tenant screening and maintenance aligns with your personal and professional goals. Managing rental properties isn’t just about collecting rent; it’s about dedicating time to ensure that your investment thrives. You’re not just a landlord; you’re a property manager, a repair person, and sometimes a mediator.

If you’re considering whether to manage your property or enlist management services, let’s talk numbers—not just in dollars, but in hours and effort.

Self-ManagementProfessional Management
Tenant screeningTime saved for other pursuits
Maintenance & RepairsProfessional handling of issues
Emergency AvailabilityPeace of mind with 24/7 support

Tenant Relations and Screening

Understanding the significance of meticulous tenant screening is crucial, as it’s the cornerstone of fostering reliable and long-lasting tenancies. As you delve into property management, you’ll soon realize that tenant relations and screening aren’t just about finding tenants; it’s about finding the right tenants. Establish a rapport built on trust and respect, and you’re more likely to have a smooth rental experience.

Effective screening of potential tenants should include:

  • Verifying income to ensure affordability
  • Checking rental history for any red flags
  • Conducting thorough background checks for security
  • Performing credit checks to assess financial reliability

Remember, these steps aren’t just about due diligence; they’re about protecting your investment and peace of mind.

Clear communication is paramount to maintaining positive tenant relations. Address issues promptly and maintain transparency to foster a sense of belonging and community among your tenants.

Maintenance and Repairs Handling

When managing rental properties, staying on top of maintenance and repairs is essential to prevent minor issues from escalating into costly problems. You, as a property owner, must be diligent in performing regular property maintenance and be ready to handle any repairs that may arise. The task is no small feat; it requires a systematic approach to coordinate with contractors and ensure preventive measures are in place.

Consider the complexity of maintenance and repairs handling. It’s a hassle that demands constant attention and the ability to deal with the burden of urgent tasks. You might find yourself questioning whether to hire a professional or tackle the job yourself. Keep in mind that property managers are adept at managing these tasks efficiently, often leveraging their networks to secure cost-effective solutions.

Moreover, property management companies can negotiate bulk rates for services, potentially lowering your expenses. They take care of the minutiae, freeing you from the day-to-day grind of repairs. As repairs might occur at any time, having a property management team ensures that issues are addressed swiftly, maintaining the value of your investment and the satisfaction of your tenants.

Being part of a community of property owners means sharing the load, and sometimes that entails entrusting experts to maintain the health of your property.

Navigating a landlord’s legal responsibilities and mitigating associated risks requires a keen understanding of property law and tenant rights. When you decide to manage your rental, you’re also taking on the role of ensuring compliance with a plethora of regulations that can vary greatly by location.

Consider the following:

  • Understanding and adhering to fair housing laws to prevent discrimination.
  • Keeping up-to-date with local ordinances and state laws concerning rental properties.
  • Maintaining the property to meet health and safety codes.
  • Handling tenant disputes and the eviction process legally and ethically.

Being well-versed in these areas is crucial to your success as a landlord and protects your Real Estate Investment. The Cons of Self-Managing often include the potential for legal oversights, which can lead to costly lawsuits or fines.

Hiring a property manager can alleviate this burden, as they typically have the expertise and resources to navigate legal responsibilities and risks efficiently. Keep in mind that hiring individual contractors for legal advice is also an option, but may not offer the same Rights Reserved protection as a dedicated property management firm.

Whatever route you choose, it’s imperative that you stay informed and proactive in your legal duties.

Professional Management Benefits

While managing the legal complexities of rental properties can be daunting, enlisting the help of professional property managers offers a wealth of benefits that streamline operations and reduce risk. You’ll find that hiring a property manager can significantly make your investment less stressful and more profitable, especially when you weigh the pros and cons.

Professional property management companies bring expertise to the table, ensuring that your rental management processes are handled effectively. They save you time by taking on tenant screening, rent collection, and the coordination of maintenance—tasks that could otherwise eat into your schedule.

Here’s a quick overview of the key benefits and considerations:

Benefits of Hiring Professional ManagementCons of Hiring
Expertise in legal compliance and tenant placementCost of services may impact your revenue
Access to cost-effective maintenance networksPotential loss of personal control over property decisions
Time-saving on day-to-day rental management tasksReliance on someone else’s judgment for tenant selection

Making the Informed Decision

Assessing the potential impact on your finances is crucial before deciding to engage a professional property management company. Keep in mind that the fees associated with property management typically range from 8-12% of your monthly rent. This doesn’t just affect your immediate cash flow; it influences the long-term profitability of your investment. As you weigh your options, consider these key points:

  • Property management fees can take a significant slice of your rental income.
  • Hiring a property manager can free up your time, potentially leading to better investment decisions elsewhere.
  • Even with a manager, you’ll need to stay involved to ensure your properties are well-cared for.
  • Thorough due diligence is essential when selecting a property management company.

You’re not just hiring a manager; you’re entrusting them with a significant investment. It’s about more than just collecting rent; it’s about finding and retaining new tenants, maintaining the property, and ultimately making sure your investment thrives.

Joining a community of property owners can provide support and insight, ensuring you’re not alone in this venture. Make sure you’re ready for the commitment and have the necessary oversight to protect your interests.

This isn’t a decision to make lightly, but with the right approach, it can significantly contribute to your financial success.


Picture yourself steering a ship through calm and stormy seas alike. Self-managing your rental is akin to captaining your own vessel; it demands your attention, skill, and time.

However, enlisting a property manager is like having a seasoned first mate, easing the burden and navigating through choppy waters.

Weigh anchor with knowledge and foresight, and choose the course that aligns with your capabilities and aspirations, ensuring your investment sails smoothly on the property seas.


Get in touch
Latest posts by Mark Draper (see all)


This site is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to We are compensated for referring traffic and business to Amazon and other companies linked to on this site. We may also do this with other affiliate schemes.

You May Also Like…

Can You Write Off Rental Property?

Can You Write Off Rental Property?

Can you confidently claim deductions on your rental property? It's a question that many landlords ponder, wondering if...